EP 312— Why Do Relationships Cause So Much Anxiety?

Why can relationships make us feel so anxious, even when they’re healthy? In this episode, we explore the psychology behind relationship anxiety and why the people we care about have such a powerful influence over our emotional wellbeing. From fear of rejection and uncertainty in modern dating to attachment patterns, vulnerability, and tying our self-worth to someone else’s behaviour, we unpack why relationships can trigger so much overthinking. Learn where relationship anxiety really comes from, why it doesn’t always mean something is wrong, and how building emotional security within yourself can help you create calmer, healthier, and more fulfilling relationships.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Hello and welcome back to and how does that make you feel an awaken podcast? I'm Jack, therapist and founder of Awaken Online Therapy, and today we're going to be discussing why relationships cause so much anxiety in people. So, why is it that someone you've only known for a few weeks can completely change how you feel? You might wake up excited because they've messaged you, then they take a little bit longer to reply, and suddenly you're questioning everything. You start wondering, have I said the wrong thing? Have they lost interest? Am I overthinking this? What's fascinating is that this isn't just something we see in the early stages of dating. People experience relationship anxiety in long-term relationships too. They worry about being left, about not being enough, about saying the wrong thing, about their partner changing their mind. So why do relationships seem to create so much anxiety? Surely, if love is meant to make us feel safe, why can it sometimes make us feel so unsettled? Today I want to explore exactly that. Because I don't think relationship anxiety is simply about being an anxious person. I think it's often about what relationships represent to us, what they activate inside of us, and why the people we care about have such a powerful influence over our emotional world. So let's start with something simple. Relationships aren't just another part of life. For most people, they're one of the most emotionally significant parts of life. Think about it for a second. The opinion of a stranger rarely ruins your day. The opinion of someone you love absolutely can. The text message from someone you barely know probably doesn't affect your mood for very long, but the message from someone you're emotionally invested in can stay on your mind all day. That's because our closest relationships matter. The more someone matters to us, the more power they naturally have to influence our emotions. And that's not weakness, that's part of being human. So here's something I don't think we talk about enough. To love someone is to give them the ability to hurt you. Now that sounds dramatic, but it's true. When you genuinely care about someone, their actions matter, their words matter, their presence matters, their absence matters, and that's because love requires vulnerability. You can't experience deep connection without allowing another person to become emotionally important to you. The difficulty is that vulnerability creates uncertainty. You can't control another person's thoughts. You can't control whether they'll always choose you. You can't guarantee they'll never leave you. And for many people that uncertainty becomes anxiety. The next thing that's important to remember is relationships often trigger old emotional patterns. Relationship anxiety rarely begins in the relationship itself. Very often the relationship simply shines a light on something that's already there. Maybe you grew up feeling rejected, maybe affection was unpredictable, maybe love felt conditional, maybe you learned that people leave. When something in your current relationship feels uncertain, those old experiences can become activated. Suddenly, today's delayed reply doesn't just feel like a delayed reply. It feels like confirmation of an old fear. That's why relationship anxiety often feels much bigger than the situation itself. Because your mind isn't only reacting to today, sometimes it's reacting to years of emotional learning. Now let's talk about the environment we're dating in. Because I genuinely think modern dating creates anxiety in ways previous generations didn't quite experience. Think about how many unanswered questions people now carry. Are we exclusive? Why did they view my story but no reply? Why are they active but haven't messaged me? What does this text actually mean? Modern dating gives us endless information, but very little certainty. We're constantly analyzing, checking, interpreting, looking for clues, and that's because our brains naturally try to reduce uncertainty. But dating often gives us more uncertainty than ever, and that's a perfect recipe for overthinking. So I think this might be one of the biggest reasons relationships create anxiety. Without realizing it, many people begin measuring their worth through another person's behavior. If they reply quickly, I feel wanted. If they're affectionate, I feel secure. If they seem distant, I question myself. But here's the problem someone else's behavior isn't always about you. People get busy, they get stressed, they have bad days, they become overwhelmed. Yet anxious minds naturally personalize everything. We assume every shift means something about us, and that is exhausting. Because now our confidence rises and falls dependent on someone else's actions. And I think another problem with anxiety is people often think that anxiety is a sign that something is wrong. Feeling anxious in a relationship doesn't always automatically mean you're with the wrong person. Sometimes anxiety is information. Sometimes it tells us something genuinely needs attention. But other times it's simply the emotional cost of caring deeply about someone. Those are two very different things. The goal isn't to eliminate every anxious feeling, the goal is to understand where it's coming from. Because once you understand it, you can respond rather than simply react. So how do we become less anxious? I don't think the answer is finding someone who magically removes every uncertainty or insecurity. Because no partner can permanently do that. Instead, I think security is something we build together through consistency, communication, honesty, repair after conflict, learning to soothe ourselves as well as leaning on someone else. And perhaps most importantly, learning that our worth exists independently of whether another person chooses us. Because whether your entire identity depends on a relationship, every small wobble is going to feel like crisis. When your identity is bigger than the relationship, those same moments become much easier to navigate. So if you do take one thing from today's episode, let it be this. Relationships create anxiety because they involve the things we care about the most. Love, connection, belonging, and the possibility of loss. The more something matters, the more emotionally vulnerable we become. That doesn't mean relationships are dangerous, it means they're meaningful. So if you found yourself overthinking text, worrying about where you stand, or feeling anxious when someone matters to you, please don't immediately assume something is wrong with you. Instead, simply get curious and ask yourself, what is this anxiety trying to protect me from? Because often the path towards healthier relationships isn't about becoming someone who never feels anxious. It's about becoming someone who understands their anxiety well enough that it no longer controls them. As always, thank you so much for listening. If you have found this podcast useful, feel free to share it with a friend or even rate us five stars on your streaming platform of choice. It really does help us reach more people. I've been Jack, and this has been And How Does That Make You Feel an Awakened Podcast, and I'll see you at the next one.